Sanibel Highlands Homes for Sale

Sanibel Highlands Homes for Sale

Welcome to Sanibel Highlands, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Sanibel, Florida! This enchanting community offers a unique blend of serene island living and modern conveniences, making it an ideal destination for those seeking a tranquil escape from the hustle and bustle of everyday life.

Sanibel Highlands is renowned for its lush landscapes, pristine beaches, and vibrant wildlife, providing residents with a picturesque setting to call home. The community is thoughtfully designed to harmonize with the natural beauty of the area, featuring charming homes that reflect the island's architectural style. Whether you’re looking for a cozy cottage or a spacious family residence, you’ll find a variety of homes for sale that cater to diverse tastes and lifestyles.

Each property in Sanibel Highlands boasts unique features, from open-concept living spaces to private outdoor retreats perfect for enjoying the warm Florida sun. Many homes are equipped with modern amenities, ensuring comfort and convenience while maintaining the island's laid-back charm. Imagine waking up to the sound of waves and enjoying your morning coffee on a sunlit patio surrounded by nature.

Beyond the stunning homes, Sanibel Highlands offers residents access to a wealth of recreational activities. Spend your weekends exploring the nearby beaches, hiking trails, and nature preserves, or indulge in the vibrant local dining and shopping scene. With a strong sense of community and an unparalleled quality of life, Sanibel Highlands invites you to discover your own slice of paradise.

Explore the available homes for sale today and take the first step toward your dream island lifestyle!

Newest Sanibel Highlands Homes for Sale

$430,000
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 2026027434 MLS
Exceptional opportunity to create your dream island retreat in one of Sanibel's most desirable locations! Situated on a spacious corner lot at 1653 Atlanta Plaza Drive, this 2-bedroom, 2-bath home offers approximately 1,200 square feet and is just a short walk or bike ride from Sanibel's world-famous shell-strewn beaches, charming boutiques, local restaurants, and vibrant shopping destinations. With the finishing touches still to be completed, this property offers the perfect opportunity to customize and design your ideal island home. Much of the heavy lifting has already been done, with major restoration and infrastructure improvements completed to provide tremendous value and peace of mind for the next owner. Recent upgrades include a new roof, impact-resistant windows and doors, new HVAC system, all-new electrical wiring and panel, new PEX plumbing throughout, and a tankless water heater. Storm mitigation has been completed, and drywall and insulation have been professionally removed approximately 3-4 feet throughout the home, creating a clean slate for your choice of finishes and personal design vision. Sanibel Island is renowned for its pristine white-sand beaches, breathtaking sunsets, abundant wildlife, and laid-back coastal lifestyle. Whether you're searching for a primary residence, seasonal getaway, vacation home, or investment opportunity, this property presents a rare chance to complete a home exactly to your tastes while enjoying one of Southwest Florida's most sought-after island communities. Bring your imagination and transform this property into the perfect Sanibel sanctuary just moments from the beach, restaurants, shops, and everything island living has to offer. Updated photos coming soon. Current photos are dated but provide a generally accurate representation of the property, and it is best appreciated in person.

1653 Atlanta Plaza Drive, Sanibel
$450,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 2026027119 MLS
Exceptional opportunity to create your dream island retreat in one of Sanibel's most desirable locations! Situated on a spacious corner lot at 1683 Atlanta Plaza Drive, this 3-bedroom, 2-bath home is just a short walk or bike ride from Sanibel's world-famous shell-strewn beaches, charming boutiques, local restaurants, and vibrant shopping destinations. Major restoration and infrastructure improvements have already been completed, providing tremendous value and peace of mind for the next owner. Recent upgrades include a new roof, impact-resistant windows and doors, new HVAC system, all-new electrical wiring and panel, new PEX plumbing throughout, and a tankless water heater. Storm mitigation has been completed, and drywall and insulation have been professionally removed approximately 3-4 feet throughout the home, creating a clean slate ready for your custom finishes and personal design vision. Sanibel Island is renowned for its pristine white-sand beaches, breathtaking sunsets, abundant wildlife, and laid-back coastal lifestyle. Whether you're searching for a primary residence, seasonal getaway, or investment opportunity, this property offers the rare chance to complete a home exactly to your tastes while enjoying one of Southwest Florida's most sought-after island communities. Bring your imagination and transform this property into the perfect Sanibel sanctuary just moments from the beach, restaurants, shops, and everything island living has to offer.

1683 Atlanta Plaza Drive, Sanibel
$950,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 2026022152 MLS
Your perfect Island getaway only minutes to the white sands of Algiers Beach! Elevated 3 bedroom 3 bath home is nestled in a peaceful Olde Florida neighborhood that is centrally located and close to shopping, dining and grocery. The home boasts an open floor plan with tile flooring, shiplap wall, vaulted ceilings, and updated kitchen giving it an open airy feel. This 2000 home has impact windows & garage doors. New roof and new siding. Bahama shutters, plus hurricane shutters. Large open space downstairs with storage for all your island toys plus an oversize garage/workshop. All three bedrooms are ensuite with pocket doors off 2nd and 3rd bedrooms. Pocket sliding glass doors off master bedroom, great room and 2nd bedroom onto 9ft wide screened upper deck overlooking pool. Oversized lot at the end of shell road adds more privacy. Relax with morning coffee on the screened front porch viewing the sunrise. Move in ready. Now's your chance to live on Island time. New Culligan water system. New AC. Lot to south of home cannot be built on or improved.

485 Peachtree Road, Sanibel
$664,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 2025003218 MLS
Welcome to The Pink Pelican Cottage! This delightful 3-bedroom, 2-bath ground-level retreat feels anything but small, with elevated ceilings creating an airy, open ambiance throughout. Completely renovated, the cottage offers an inviting blend of modern comforts and casual coastal style. The bright kitchen flows seamlessly into the spacious living and dining areas, perfect for relaxing after a day at the beach or entertaining family and friends. Thoughtful storage throughout the home makes it ideal not only as a vacation getaway, but also as a comfortable full-time residence. Furnishings may be purchased separately, creating an easy turnkey opportunity. Step outside to your own private outdoor oasis surrounded by lush tropical landscaping. Whether enjoying morning coffee, hosting a sunset gathering, or simply unwinding with a good book, the expansive sitting and patio areas extend the living space and capture the laid-back Sanibel lifestyle. Beyond the charm and character, the home also offers valuable peace of mind with numerous completed improvements, including a metal roof, impact windows and doors, updated systems, and newly installed flood barriers already in place. Conveniently located near beaches, bike paths, restaurants, Jerry’s, shopping, and easy on/off island access, The Pink Pelican Cottage offers the rare combination of island charm, modern updates, and thoughtful preparedness in one beautifully maintained​​‌​​​​‌​‌​​​​‌‌​​‌‌​‌‌​​‌​​​‌​‌ package.

1657 Atlanta Plaza Drive, Sanibel
Start Your Search